To Floor..

--------------------------

Hi Floor,

Yes, you are absolutely right that some additional aspects of the problem have to be further clarified and discussed. And here they are.

--------------------------------------

1) Actually the correct equation is

V x I x t = (I x I x R x t) + (Z x I x t x (HHV)) + (X) (1B),

where

V x I x t = input energy = electric energy, which is generated by the DC source, and which is consumed by the electrolyzer

I x I x R x t = Q = Joule's heat, which is generated by the electrolyzer = output energy 1

Z x I x t x (HHV) = output energy 2 = heat, which is generated by burning/exploding of the released hydrogen

X = output energy 3 = sum of all additional energies, which are necessary (a) for splitting of water molecules into hydrogen and oxygen atoms, (b) for collateral chemical reactions due to the impurity of the electrolyte, (c) for forming of bubbles etc., etc.

----------------------------------

2) It is evident from the above equality (1B) that (V x I x t) is the sum and that (I x I x R x t), (Z x I x t x (HHV)) and (X) are the addends, respectively.

----------------------------------

3) According to the rules of standard arithmetic the sum is always bigger than any of the addends (forming that same sum). Therefore the

sum (V x I x t) is bigger than the addend (I x I x R x t). Therefore we can write down the inequality V x I x t > I x I x R x t (2B).

----------------------------------

4) Now let us divide both sides of inequality (2B) by (I x t), that is,

V x I x t > I x I x R x t (2B) < = >

< = > (V x I x t)/(I x t) > (I x I x R x t)/(I x t) (3B) < = >

< = > V > I x R (4B).

-----------------------------------

5) The last inequality (4B) as if shows a violation of Ohm's law. Because the correct mathematical expression for Ohm's law is V = I x R (5B), isn't it?

----------------------------------

Everything in the above considerations seems to be logically and mathematically correct, doesn't it? What is your opinion?

(I am not pressing you to accept the validity of anything at once. We are simply seeking for the truth together. I am not in a hurry. I will be patient. I promise.

)

Looking forward to your answer.

Respectfully yours,

George